Is online counselling really as effective as face-to-face therapy?
-reflections from a licensed clinical psychologist in London specialising in South Asian mental health
The Shift Toward Online Therapy
In today’s always-on culture, therapy has quietly entered a new era—one that doesn’t require a waiting room. For many South Asians living in urban UK cities like London, where career ambitions, family responsibilities, and cultural expectations collide, online counselling has emerged as more than just a convenient option—it’s become a gateway to finally seeking help without disrupting the rhythm of life.
But beyond convenience, there’s a deeper, less-discussed shift happening: online therapy is challenging traditional perceptions of emotional connection, privacy, and legitimacy in mental health care. Particularly for those navigating cultural nuances with a South Asian therapist or clinical psychologist in London, the question arises—can meaningful healing really happen through a screen?
This article explores whether online counselling is as effective as face-to-face therapy, and why the answer might depend less on the format and more on how well the therapy meets your personal, cultural, and psychological needs.
Why more people are choosing online therapy
For South Asians in the UK, especially professionals between 28–45 balancing demanding careers and familyexpectations, online therapy is more than just a time-saver—it’s a lifeline. The shift toward digital sessions reflects not only the need for flexibility but also a quiet rebellion against long-standing cultural stigma around seeking psychological support.
Many find that speaking with an Indian therapist or South Asian psychologist online reduces the fear of being seen, judged, or misunderstood—common concerns within tightly-knit communities. With privacy, control, and accessibility at their fingertips, clients can begin therapy in environments that feel safe and familiar.
Urban living in cities like London means busy schedules and long commutes (I understand, I’ve been there!). Online sessions remove logistical barriers and make therapy feel more approachable, especially for first-timers who might hesitate to walk into a therapist’s office. For many, it’s the first step toward emotional clarity that fits into the life they’re already living.
Key Differences Between Online and Face-to-Face Therapy
While the goals of therapy remain consistent, the experience of online versus in-person counselling can feel vastly different. Understanding these differences helps clients make informed decisions about what suits them best.
Here are some key distinctions:
Communication style: Online therapy may rely more on verbal cues, while face-to-face sessions benefit from observing full body language and physical presence.
Environment: In-person therapy offers a neutral, contained space; online sessions often happen at home, which can affect openness or distraction levels.
Tech challenges: Connectivity issues and digital fatigue may disrupt online sessions, though many adapt quickly.
Accessibility: Online sessions eliminate travel time and allow for greater scheduling flexibility.
Cultural comfort: Working with a South Asian therapist online can feel less intimidating and more discreet, especially for those concerned about community visibility.
What the Research Says About Effectiveness
There’s a growing body of evidence suggesting that online therapy can be just as effective as face-to-face counselling—particularly for common concerns like anxiety, depression, stress, and relationship issues. But what’s often left out of the conversation is why online therapy works so well, especially for people navigating multiple cultural, social, and emotional identities.
A 2022 meta-analysis published in the Journal of Affective Disorders found that internet-based cognitive behavioural therapy (iCBT) was equally effective as in-person CBT for treating mild to moderate depression. But clinical outcomes are just part of the picture. Emotional availability, cultural resonance, and consistency in attendance play significant roles—factors especially relevant to South Asian clients balancing career pressures, familial expectations, and cultural norms.
What doesn’t get talked about enough is how online therapy removes the invisible emotional barriers many South Asians face when considering counselling. The act of showing up to a physical office can stir up fears of judgment—from within and from the broader community. Online therapy creates an in-between space—private, safe, and under the client’s control—which can be essential for building initial trust.
Another under-discussed benefit is continuity. South Asians in the UK often travel to visit extended family, manage hybrid work models, or relocate within cities. Online sessions allow clients to maintain therapeutic momentum despite life’s unpredictability. This kind of uninterrupted emotional support can significantly boost outcomes over time.
When therapy is delivered by a South Asian psychologist or clinical psychologist in London who understands cultural nuance, the digital medium does not dilute its impact. In fact, for many, it amplifies accessibility and emotional safety—two vital components of successful therapy that often go unmeasured in traditional research studies.
Cultural sensitivity and connection: Does format matter?
One of the quiet myths about therapy is that emotional connection only happens in the room. For many from South Asian backgrounds, especially first- or second-generation professionals in the UK, the question isn’t just “Can I connect with my therapist online?”—it’s “Will my therapist understand where I’m coming from at all?”
Whether therapy is online or in-person, cultural sensitivity is the true connector. The therapeutic bond is less about format and more about familiarity—with values, unspoken family rules, and the emotional grammar that exists between South Asian parents and children, spouses, and siblings.
Many South Asian clients report deeper comfort when working with a South Asian therapist or Indian therapist who shares a cultural framework—even through a screen. This recognition, even if implicit, makes it easier to explore sensitive topics like parental pressure, identity conflict, or marital roles shaped by tradition.
“The cultural fit between client and therapist often outweighs the setting in which therapy is delivered,” says Dr. Rina Bajaj, a UK-based counselling psychologist and author. “A culturally competent therapist can create safety and rapport whether online or in-person.”
Online therapy can even enhance cultural safety. Some clients feel freer to speak openly about taboo subjects—mental illness, sexual orientation, or interfaith relationships—when not face-to-face. The screen provides a gentle distance, allowing space for honesty before emotional closeness fully develops.
In essence, when cultural alignment exists, the format fades into the background. What remains is the relationship, and that’s what ultimately drives transformation.
When Face-to-Face might be more suitable
While online therapy is highly effective for many, there are times when face-to-face sessions offer unique benefits—especially when deeper containment, embodied presence, or physical cues are critical to the therapeutic process.
For South Asian clients working through complex trauma, generational grief, or dissociation, the physical space of a therapy room can provide a kind of grounding that’s hard to replicate online. The act of arriving, sitting in a neutral space, and being witnessed in real time without digital mediation can offer a form of containment that feels emotionally regulating.
In households where privacy is limited—such as multigenerational living situations—face-to-face therapy may also offer a more secure setting for open expression. This is especially important when discussing taboo topics like sexuality, emotional neglect, or conflict with elders.
Some clients also find that physical presence enhances emotional connection. For them, non-verbal nuances—like a pause, a reassuring nod, or shared silence—carry therapeutic weight. In such cases, in-person therapy with a therapist who understands both the emotional complexity and the cultural context can feel not only appropriate but necessary.
Still, the key isn’t format—it’s fit.
Choosing therapy that matches your emotional readiness, lifestyle, and relational needs is more important than whether it’s delivered online or in-person. A culturally attuned Indian or South Asian therapist can help guide that decision collaboratively.
How to choose what’s right for YOU.
Choosing between online and face-to-face therapy isn’t just about logistics—it’s about emotional alignment. For South Asian individuals balancing personal growth with cultural expectations, the right format depends on where you feel most seen and supported.
Ask yourself:
Do I have a private space where I can speak freely without interruption?
Am I more likely to commit to therapy if I can access it from home?
Do I feel emotionally safe enough to explore difficult topics without physical presence?
Would meeting in person help me feel more grounded and connected?
Some clients begin with online therapy and later shift to face-to-face as their needs evolve—or vice versa. A psychologist who offers a hybrid model may provide the flexibility to adapt over time.
If cultural understanding is a priority, working with a South Asian therapist—regardless of format—can make all the difference. It’s not just about being heard. It’s about being understood.
Ultimately, the most important factor is that you feel seen, heard, and empowered. Therapy is not one-size-fits-all, and choosing the right format can be a pivotal step in your mental health journey. With the flexibility of online sessions and the grounding presence of in-person therapy, there’s no limit to how you can start working through your mental health challenges today.
————————————————————————————————————————-
About the Author
Raisa Luther is a registered Clinical Psychologist based in London, UK, offering virtual therapy services across the UK. She is trained in multiple trauma-focused modalities, including EMDR, and is passionate about helping clients move from merely surviving to thriving. Her approach is rooted in compassion, cultural sensitivity, and a deep belief that healing can be both fast and lasting.
